|2||murdered||employer||madness||you liked it.|
|3||attacked||teacher||addiction||you'd do it again.|
|4||swindled||debtors||fear||you almost got away with it.|
|5||robbed||community||jealousy||it needed to be done.|
|6||abandoned||position||love||you have nothing to show for it.|
|7||slighted||liege||desperation||they can't really prove it.|
|8||deserted||spouse||vengeance||your memory is hazy.|
|9||obeyed||child||conviction||it gnaws at you.|
|10||denounced||land||greed||you were ordered to.|
|11||defamed||ancestors||inaction||there was precedent.|
|12||blasphemed||church||curiosity||you were framed.|
Each column is very broadly ranged from material/carnal to conceptual/intellectual which could allow different settings to tweak their results for each fairly easily with a positive or negative modifier. Like if you wanted characters with reasonable doubt as to their guilt, add 4 to your roll in the last column.
- You slighted your spouse out of vengeance but they can't really prove it.
- You obeyed your liege out of love but there was precedent.
- You defamed your liege out of desperation but you have nothing to show for it.
- You murdered your ancestors out of inaction but you almost got away with it.